The Rule That Could Cost NAR Half Its Members

The Rule That Could Cost NAR Half Its Members

There’s a crisis in the real estate industry, and it starts with the industry’s own advocacy group, the National Association of Realtors. Yes, the very group that’s supposed to be advocating for us. Somewhere along the way, NAR got into the business of policing how we sell homes in all fifty states. Last I checked, real estate was still local.

There’s a policy so controversial that its mere existence could be NAR’s downfall. To understand why, we have to look under the hood at a few of the big stories everybody in the industry is talking about. This policy—this “rule”—has needed so much explaining that by now it ought to be called “Can’t Clearly Police.”

If you’re in the industry, you already know the one. The Clear Cooperation Policy, or simply CCP. And yes, “cooperation” is a curious word for something enforced with an iron fist (USSR pun intended, the wall collapse is coming).

NAR adopted CCP in late 2019 and gave affiliated multiple listing services until May 2020 to implement it. Once a broker publicly markets a covered listing, that broker has one business day to put it in the local multiple listing service, or MLS, where competing agents can see it. The idea is a good one. A family moving to Iowa City should be able to find a home regardless of which brokerage answers their first call.

But wait. Back up. How does a trade advocacy group get the power to write a rule that reaches all the way down to my local MLS in Iowa City? Yeah, now you’re starting to see where the overreach comes in. Enter the three-way agreement.

When I join my local Realtor association, I also belong to the state association and to NAR. Yes, all three. Each MLS decides, subject to state law, whether association membership is a condition of access. But here’s what that structure looks like from my desk. NAR writes a policy, our local MLS puts it into its rules, and an agent here in Iowa City can get fined for violating those rules.

A trade organization that should be advocating for housing, sharing best practices, and providing leadership has taken to wearing a police badge. The problem? A policy somebody needs in one market can create a mess in another. Try to solve one problem and, sure enough, you’ve created three more.

CCP complicated agents’ ability to share information across brokerages. In my market, it created tribalism. Take an office exclusive. With the seller’s authorization, word can travel through the listing brokerage. Share it through a network that includes other brokerages, and that counts as public marketing. NAR would later clarify (because apparently the policy wasn't confusing enough already) that a one-to-one conversation between brokers doesn’t, by itself, start the clock.

Here in Iowa City, the effect was pretty simple. When agents worried that sharing an upcoming listing outside the company could draw a fine, they leaned harder on the people inside it. Think about the irony. A rule meant to get more listings out into the open gave brokerages a reason to double down internally. And if you want more agents to hear about your internal listings? Get a bigger brokerage.

Fast-forward five years. In 2025, five brokerages accounted for nearly a quarter of U.S. residential real estate sales volume. Then the biggest one bought the second-biggest. In January, Compass bought Anywhere, the parent company of Coldwell Banker, Century 21, Sotheby’s International Realty, and more. In May, eXp’s parent company bought NextHome. In August, The Real Brokerage bought RE/MAX. Plenty of forces drove those deals. My point is simpler. Once you give the people inside a brokerage an advantage in who hears about a house first, every agent you bring inside makes that advantage worth more.

The mergers supplied the spark. The fight over “Coming Soon” poured gasoline on it. With more agents under the same roof, smaller brokerages had even more reason to worry about which listings their buyers might be missing. My read, after going through a few reports? Among the people calling for change, it felt about 50–50. Half wanted CCP reformed. The other half wanted it repealed entirely. Think about that—even the people willing to keep it thought it needed fixing!!

And here’s where the plot thickens. In March 2025, NAR leadership had a chance to repeal CCP. Instead? They doubled down!! They kept the rule and amended it...added a 'delayed-marketing’ option (well ‘optional' for the seller...but mandated to all local associations). Here in Iowa City, a seller can sign a disclosure so other agents can see the home in our MLS while it stays off the public listing feeds. I welcomed that flexibility…though it did create new complexities…and I still think NAR should have repealed the rule when it had the chance.

As a member, I found that disheartening. The Burnett commission case (you know, the big sensational headline) was filed before NAR even adopted CCP. It was about buyer-broker compensation. But by the time NAR took another look at CCP, it had already lost the Burnett verdict and agreed to a $418 million settlement. You’d think an experience that expensive might make a trade group think twice about writing rules for everybody. So what happens next? Well, lawsuits, of course!

Compass sued Zillow over Zillow’s own listing standards and later dropped the suit. In the meantime, Compass struck a deal with Rocket to put its Coming Soon listings on Redfin. Imagine explaining that to a buyer who thought searching for a home online meant they were seeing the homes for sale. Now part of my job is explaining which companies made a deal with each other.

Okay, bigger brokerages through mergers and acquisitions…then came lawsuits…what next? Meanwhile, four big real estate companies have announced plans for their own “housing exchange.” They’re calling it, 'Open Real Estate.' They say it’s designed to work alongside local MLSs. Choosing a technology vendor is on the calendar for early 2027 with a launch date still up in the air. But you can see the challenge coming for the one thing I think NAR counts on to hold its membership together. The MLS.

See, our local association operates an MLS where agents share information about homes for sale. For plenty of agents around here, that’s the reason to join in the first place. And once you join the local association, the state and national associations come with it. Remember the three-way agreement?

So what happens to the local association’s membership, and therefore the state’s and NAR’s, if a competing exchange takes hold? Say you joined for the listings. You’re fed up with the rules. Now you can get the listings somewhere else. When the dues bill comes, why would you stay?

The consequences could be huge for a trade organization that’s been around for more than a century. NAR set out to control how listings are shared. It may have given its own members a reason to figure out how to share them without NAR.

And this isn’t the result I want. I suspect plenty of my colleagues feel the same way. Here in Iowa City, locally owned brokerages are a big part of our market. Agents at different companies rely on each other for information about upcoming listings. I might have a listing. They might have a buyer. We’re in the matchmaking business!

That’s what bothers me most about CCP. I’ve watched it erode trust between people who used to pick up the phone and call each other. And the rule itself? Yeah, this summer NAR put out another round of guidance on office exclusives and pre-marketing. That’s right—ANOTHER amendment!! Because it didn’t work the first time…so NAR amended it…and then it still didn’t work, so they amended it again!!

By the time you’ve read the rule, the companion policy, and the clarification, try telling another agent exactly what they can do. Somewhere along the way, what I used to call a dumb policy graduated to a stupid one. It’s an attempt to govern the impossible. And as long as it’s around, it’ll keep dividing us. If the new exchange delivers on its promise, frustrated members may finally have a choice.

I think NAR could lose half its members over the next twenty years. That’s my prediction, and frankly, I hope I’m wrong. I value our local association. I’ve volunteered my time there because getting agents from competing companies in the same room makes us better at our jobs. I’d hate to see our local association lose a good member because that member is fed up with decisions made at the national level.

You want to give me a reason to keep paying national dues? Fight for the family trying to afford a home. Help those of us working on housing supply make our case to lawmakers. I can call the agent across town myself. But getting the attention of Congress? That’s where I could use some backup!

My vote is the same one I would have cast before the last round of clarifications. Repeal Clear Cooperation. Stop policing how we talk to each other and get back to advocating for housing. I’d like to keep being a member of that organization.

Work With Us

Etiam non quam lacus suspendisse faucibus interdum. Orci ac auctor augue mauris augue neque. Bibendum at varius vel pharetra. Viverra orci sagittis eu volutpat. Platea dictumst vestibulum rhoncus est pellentesque elit ullamcorper.

Follow Me on Instagram